> > Page 2 of 4

Items + Gifts Under $5

Shop funny, unique, cheap gifts for Christmas, Valentine's Day, and other holidays. Not just gifts under $10 or $20—this is everything in our online shop for $5 or less!

Can't decide on a gift? Get a Strange Ways Gift Card, and they can pick what they want!

Diamond Mini Sticker Patch

Diamond Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Rainbow Pride Heart Mini Sticker Patch

Rainbow Pride Heart Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99 Sold Out
Coffee Cup Mini Sticker Patch

Coffee Cup Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Deluxe Metal Pin Backs (Set of 5)

Deluxe Metal Pin Backs (Set of 5)

Strange Ways $ 4.99
Nope! Hand Mini Sticker Patch

Nope! Hand Mini Sticker Patch

Valley Cruise Press $ 4.99
New Haven Apizza Sticker (Set of 3)

New Haven Apizza Sticker (Set of 3)

Strange Ways $ 2.99
Extra Rubber Pin Backs - Magenta (Set of 15)

Extra Rubber Pin Backs - Magenta (Set of 15)

Strange Ways $ 2.99
Sale
Running From Myself Patch

Running From Myself Patch

Ball & Chain Co. $ 7.99 $ 4.99
Sale
American Hockey League - Beast Of New Haven Pin

American Hockey League - Beast Of New Haven Pin

Strange Ways $ 7.99 $ 4.99
Sweetest Kittens Sharpest Claws Big Pinback Button

Sweetest Kittens Sharpest Claws Big Pinback Button

Rosehound Apparel $ 3.99
Cherries Mini Sticker Patch

Cherries Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
White Cat Mini Sticker Patch

White Cat Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Strange Ways Pinback Button (Set of 2)

Strange Ways Pinback Button (Set of 2)

Strange Ways $ 2.99
Sale
Trespassing Keychain

Trespassing Keychain

Explorer's Press $ 6.99 $ 1.99
Sale
Free As A Bird Keychain

Free As A Bird Keychain

Three Potato Four $ 7.99 $ 2.99
VHS Sticker (Set of 3)

VHS Sticker (Set of 3)

Strange Ways $ 2.99
Sale
This Is A Way Of Life! Patch

This Is A Way Of Life! Patch

Goblinko Megamall $ 7.99 $ 4.99
Rocketship Mini Sticker Patch

Rocketship Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99 Sold Out
Robot Head Mini Sticker Patch

Robot Head Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Extra Rubber Pin Backs - Yellow (Set of 15)

Extra Rubber Pin Backs - Yellow (Set of 15)

Strange Ways $ 2.99
Sale
Eat Your Heart Out Pin

Eat Your Heart Out Pin

Sick Girls $ 9.99 $ 4.99
Camera Flash Mini Sticker Patch

Camera Flash Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Palm Reader Mini Sticker Patch

Palm Reader Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Sale
Lesbian Subway Sign Patch

Lesbian Subway Sign Patch

Butch & Sissy $ 7.99 $ 2.99
Desert Cactus Mini Sticker Patch

Desert Cactus Mini Sticker Patch

Valley Cruise Press $ 4.99
Monstera Leaf Mini Sticker Patch

Monstera Leaf Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Sale
Chocolate Frosted Donut Pin

Chocolate Frosted Donut Pin

These Are Things $ 9.99 $ 4.99
Pot Leaf Face Mini Sticker Patch

Pot Leaf Face Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Naps For Days Mini Sticker Patch

Naps For Days Mini Sticker Patch

Valley Cruise Press $ 4.99
Mixtape Mini Sticker Patch

Mixtape Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Sale
Dickhead Pin

Dickhead Pin

Ball & Chain Co. $ 9.99 $ 4.99
Sale
Cowboy Boots Pin

Cowboy Boots Pin

Explorer's Press $ 8.99 $ 2.99
Stop Asking Questions Fabric Patch

Stop Asking Questions Fabric Patch

Toast Designs $ 4.99
Strange Ways Round Sticker (Set of 3)

Strange Ways Round Sticker (Set of 3)

Strange Ways $ 2.99
Sale
Jessi Preston Peacock Patch

Jessi Preston Peacock Patch

Explorer's Press $ 7.99 $ 4.99
Donut Mini Sticker Patch

Donut Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99 Sold Out
Fox Mini Sticker Patch

Fox Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
RESIST Sticker - Red, White, & Blue (Set of 3)

RESIST Sticker - Red, White, & Blue (Set of 3)

Strange Ways $ 2.99
Sale
I Don't Care Big Pinback Button

I Don't Care Big Pinback Button

The Pulp Girls $ 2.99 $ 0.99
Sale
Bird Hunter Vintage Pin

Bird Hunter Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 6.99 $ 1.99
Sale
An Eaten Apple Pin

An Eaten Apple Pin

We Are Out Of Office $ 4.99 Sold Out
Sale
Grey Fox Pin

Grey Fox Pin

Ashlea Bechaz $ 11.99 $ 4.99
Greatest Hits Sticker Sheet

Greatest Hits Sticker Sheet

Stay Home Club $ 4.99 Sold Out
Paint Palette Mini Sticker Patch

Paint Palette Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99 Sold Out
Sale
Piss Off Creep Patch

Piss Off Creep Patch

Bananna Bones $ 6.99 $ 4.99
Friend Of The Devil Mini Patch

Friend Of The Devil Mini Patch

World Famous Original $ 4.99 Sold Out
Nuke The Homophobes Bumper Sticker

Nuke The Homophobes Bumper Sticker

Explorer's Press $ 3.99
Rainbow Heart Mini Sticker Patch

Rainbow Heart Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99