> > Page 2 of 4

Items + Gifts Under $5

Shop funny, unique, cheap gifts for Christmas, Valentine's Day, and other holidays. Not just gifts under $10 or $20—this is everything in our online shop for $5 or less!

Can't decide on a gift? Get a Strange Ways Gift Card, and they can pick what they want!

Sale
Get Over It Cowboy Patch

Get Over It Cowboy Patch

Gentlepersons Gently $ 5.99 $ 3.99
Still Sleepy Large Refrigerator Magnet

Still Sleepy Large Refrigerator Magnet

Stay Home Club $ 3.99
Stay Home Club Large Refrigerator Magnet

Stay Home Club Large Refrigerator Magnet

Stay Home Club $ 3.99 Sold Out
Cautious Optimism Large Refrigerator Magnet

Cautious Optimism Large Refrigerator Magnet

Stay Home Club $ 3.99
Frequent Crier Program Large Refrigerator Magnet

Frequent Crier Program Large Refrigerator Magnet

Stay Home Club $ 3.99
World's Laziest Workaholic Large Refrigerator Magnet

World's Laziest Workaholic Large Refrigerator Magnet

Stay Home Club $ 3.99
Three Eyed Wolf Sticker (Holographic)

Three Eyed Wolf Sticker (Holographic)

Band Of Weirdos $ 3.99
Weird Woman Sticker (Holographic)

Weird Woman Sticker (Holographic)

Band Of Weirdos $ 3.99
Feminist Snake Sticker

Feminist Snake Sticker

Band Of Weirdos $ 3.99
Sale
Mean Girls - Hair Full Of Secrets Patch

Mean Girls - Hair Full Of Secrets Patch

Strange Ways $ 9.99 $ 3.99
Frida Kahlo Sticker

Frida Kahlo Sticker

Culture Flock $ 3.99
Ghoul Gang Sticker

Ghoul Gang Sticker

Culture Flock $ 3.99
Very Queer Big Pinback Button

Very Queer Big Pinback Button

Bianca Designs $ 3.99
Lookin' For Some Lovin' Big Pinback Button

Lookin' For Some Lovin' Big Pinback Button

Sidewinder Goods $ 3.99
Friends Of Nature Big Pinback Button

Friends Of Nature Big Pinback Button

Ello There $ 3.99
Sale
Skull & Combs Patch

Skull & Combs Patch

Skull & Combs Co. $ 5.99 $ 3.99
Cobra Skull Big Pinback Button

Cobra Skull Big Pinback Button

Hungry Ghost Press $ 3.99
Sweetest Kittens Sharpest Claws Big Pinback Button

Sweetest Kittens Sharpest Claws Big Pinback Button

Rosehound Apparel $ 3.99 Sold Out
I Brake For Breakfast Bumper Sticker

I Brake For Breakfast Bumper Sticker

Monsters Outside $ 3.99
Nuke The Homophobes Bumper Sticker

Nuke The Homophobes Bumper Sticker

Explorer's Press $ 3.99
Honk If You Are On Drugs Bumper Sticker

Honk If You Are On Drugs Bumper Sticker

Explorer's Press $ 3.99
Ignorance Is Bliss Bumper Sticker (Reflective 3M)

Ignorance Is Bliss Bumper Sticker (Reflective 3M)

Explorer's Press $ 3.99
I'm Not Speeding... I'm Running From My Problems! Bumper Sticker

I'm Not Speeding... I'm Running From My Problems! Bumper Sticker

Explorer's Press $ 3.99
No Fun Bumper Sticker

No Fun Bumper Sticker

No Fun Press $ 3.99 Sold Out
Heart-Shaped Rubber Pin Backs - Assorted (Set of 9)

Heart-Shaped Rubber Pin Backs - Assorted (Set of 9)

The Pin Department $ 3.99
Heart-Shaped Rubber Pin Backs - Black (Set of 9)

Heart-Shaped Rubber Pin Backs - Black (Set of 9)

The Pin Department $ 3.99
Heart-Shaped Rubber Pin Backs - Glitter (Set of 9)

Heart-Shaped Rubber Pin Backs - Glitter (Set of 9)

The Pin Department $ 3.99
Heart-Shaped Rubber Pin Backs - Pink (Set of 9)

Heart-Shaped Rubber Pin Backs - Pink (Set of 9)

The Pin Department $ 3.99
Mystery $4 Vintage Pin

Mystery $4 Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 3.99
666 Metal Skull Big Pinback Button

666 Metal Skull Big Pinback Button

Hungry Ghost Press $ 3.99
Garbage Pail Kids Vintage Big Pinback Button

Garbage Pail Kids Vintage Big Pinback Button

Topps $ 3.99
Frequent Meltdown Card

Frequent Meltdown Card

Adam J. Kurtz $ 3.99 Sold Out
Sale
Clueless - Cell Phone & Beeper Pin Set

Clueless - Cell Phone & Beeper Pin Set

Strange Ways $ 19.99 $ 2.99
Cupcake Face Mini Sticker Patch

Cupcake Face Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Four Leaf Clover Mini Sticker Patch

Four Leaf Clover Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99 Sold Out
French Fries Face Mini Sticker Patch

French Fries Face Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Love Letter Mini Sticker Patch

Love Letter Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Palm Tree Mini Sticker Patch

Palm Tree Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Annoyed By Everything Sticker

Annoyed By Everything Sticker

No Fun Press $ 2.99
Innocence Sticker

Innocence Sticker

Ball & Chain Co. $ 2.99
Sale
Clueless - Herbal Refreshment Pin

Clueless - Herbal Refreshment Pin

Strange Ways $ 13.99 $ 2.99
Sale
Clueless - Cakeboy Pin

Clueless - Cakeboy Pin

Strange Ways $ 13.99 $ 2.99
Sale
Mean Girls - Queen Bee Pin

Mean Girls - Queen Bee Pin

Strange Ways $ 13.99 $ 2.99
Sale
Mean Girls - Baby Prostitute Perfume Pin

Mean Girls - Baby Prostitute Perfume Pin

Strange Ways $ 13.99 $ 2.99
Carry Yourself Sticker

Carry Yourself Sticker

Adam J. Kurtz $ 2.99 Sold Out
Do What You Love Sticker

Do What You Love Sticker

Adam J. Kurtz $ 2.99
Sale
WOOOO!! Hand Pin

WOOOO!! Hand Pin

Immunity $ 7.99 $ 2.99
Lift A Finger Sticker

Lift A Finger Sticker

No Fun Press $ 2.99