> > Page 2 of 3

Items + Gifts Under $5

Shop funny, unique, unusual gifts for Christmas, Valentine's Day, and birthdays. This is everything In Stock in our online shop for $5 or less!

Can't decide on a gift? Get a Strange Ways Gift Card, and they can pick what they want!

Femme Power Big Pinback Button

Femme Power Big Pinback Button

Creepy Gals $ 2.99
Pit Hair, Don't Care Big Pinback Button

Pit Hair, Don't Care Big Pinback Button

Creepy Gals $ 2.99
Sale
Cat Coven - Cat Coven Emblem Patch

Cat Coven - Cat Coven Emblem Patch

Cat Coven $ 7.99 $ 4.99
Sale
Two Leaf Clover Club Patch

Two Leaf Clover Club Patch

Frog and Toad Press $ 6.99 $ 4.99
Sale
Akira - We The Heroes Ball Star Pin

Akira - We The Heroes Ball Star Pin

Akira $ 9.99 $ 4.99
Sale
I'd Diet But... Vintage Pin

I'd Diet But... Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 6.99 $ 4.99
I May Be Old, But I Still Get Hot Vintage Patch

I May Be Old, But I Still Get Hot Vintage Patch

Strange Ways $ 4.99
Sale
Cobra Skull Big Pinback Button

Cobra Skull Big Pinback Button

Hungry Ghost Press $ 3.99 $ 2.99
Sale
Summer Orlando Pin

Summer Orlando Pin

Summer Orlando $ 9.99 $ 1.99
Sale
Kiki Lucia - Let's Have A Kiki Pin

Kiki Lucia - Let's Have A Kiki Pin

Kiki Lucia $ 9.99 $ 4.99
Sale
Joslyn Fox Pin

Joslyn Fox Pin

Joslyn Fox $ 9.99 $ 2.99
Babashook (Gay Babadook) Sticker (Set of 3)

Babashook (Gay Babadook) Sticker (Set of 3)

Strange Ways $ 2.99
Not Your Bitch Sticker

Not Your Bitch Sticker

Notes To Self $ 2.99
Love Love Love Sticker

Love Love Love Sticker

Notes To Self $ 2.99
Sale
Rosehound Apparel - Bad Seed Merit Badge Mini Patch

Rosehound Apparel - Bad Seed Merit Badge Mini Patch

Rosehound Apparel $ 5.99 $ 1.99
Sale
Nuke The Homophobes Bumper Sticker

Nuke The Homophobes Bumper Sticker

Explorer's Press $ 4.99 $ 2.99
Ignorance Is Bliss Bumper Sticker (Reflective 3M)

Ignorance Is Bliss Bumper Sticker (Reflective 3M)

Explorer's Press $ 4.99
I'm Not Speeding... I'm Running From My Problems! Bumper Sticker

I'm Not Speeding... I'm Running From My Problems! Bumper Sticker

Explorer's Press $ 4.99
Sketchy Sticker Sheet

Sketchy Sticker Sheet

Stay Home Club $ 3.99
Throwback Sticker Sheet

Throwback Sticker Sheet

Stay Home Club $ 3.99
Donut Mini Sticker Patch

Donut Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Sale
Shit I'll Never Get Done Notepad

Shit I'll Never Get Done Notepad

Terrapin Stationers $ 7.99 $ 4.99
Heart-Shaped Rubber Pin Backs - Assorted (Set of 9)

Heart-Shaped Rubber Pin Backs - Assorted (Set of 9)

The Pin Department $ 3.99
Heart-Shaped Rubber Pin Backs - Black (Set of 9)

Heart-Shaped Rubber Pin Backs - Black (Set of 9)

The Pin Department $ 3.99
Sale
Mean Girls - Hair Full Of Secrets Patch

Mean Girls - Hair Full Of Secrets Patch

Strange Ways $ 9.99 $ 1.99
Sale
Clueless - Cakeboy Pin

Clueless - Cakeboy Pin

Strange Ways $ 13.99 $ 1.99
Sale
Clueless - Herbal Refreshment Pin

Clueless - Herbal Refreshment Pin

Strange Ways $ 13.99 $ 1.99
Sale
I Am Woman Keychain - Pink

I Am Woman Keychain - Pink

Three Potato Four $ 7.99 $ 3.99
Sale
I Am Woman Keychain - Black

I Am Woman Keychain - Black

Three Potato Four $ 7.99 $ 3.99
Rainbow Pride Heart Mini Sticker Patch

Rainbow Pride Heart Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Sale
Rainbow Heart Mini Sticker Patch

Rainbow Heart Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99 $ 1.99
Paint Palette Mini Sticker Patch

Paint Palette Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Tiger Mini Sticker Patch

Tiger Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Sale
Monkey Mini Sticker Patch

Monkey Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99 $ 1.99
Fox Mini Sticker Patch

Fox Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
French BullDog Dog Mini Sticker Patch

French BullDog Dog Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Chihuahua Dog Mini Sticker Patch

Chihuahua Dog Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Beagle Dog Mini Sticker Patch

Beagle Dog Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Sale
Teatotaller - Chai-Curious Pin

Teatotaller - Chai-Curious Pin

Teatotaller $ 9.99 $ 3.99
Sale
Marijuana Leaf Shield Vintage Pin

Marijuana Leaf Shield Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99 $ 1.99
Palm Reader Mini Sticker Patch

Palm Reader Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Sale
Shea Coulee - Do I Look Upset To You? Mirror Pin

Shea Coulee - Do I Look Upset To You? Mirror Pin

Shea Couleé $ 9.99 $ 2.99
Sale
Babashook (Gay Babadook) Pin

Babashook (Gay Babadook) Pin

Strange Ways $ 9.99 $ 2.99
Mystery $4 Vintage Pin

Mystery $4 Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 3.99
666 Metal Skull Big Pinback Button

666 Metal Skull Big Pinback Button

Hungry Ghost Press $ 3.99
Coffee Cup Mini Sticker Patch

Coffee Cup Mini Sticker Patch

These Are Things $ 2.99
Extra Metal Pin Backs (Set of 15)

Extra Metal Pin Backs (Set of 15)

Strange Ways $ 2.99
Garbage Pail Kids Vintage Big Pinback Button

Garbage Pail Kids Vintage Big Pinback Button

Topps $ 3.99