Vintage Items

Like-new, old stock we've rediscovered from the past. Pins, patches, trading cards, and more in limited supply!
Sale

Don't Tell Me How It Is Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99 $ 2.99
Sale

I Mistook Love For Sex Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99 $ 1.49

Mr. Wonderful Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99

Irish Lover Four Leaf Clover Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99
Sale

I'd Diet But... Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99 $ 1.49

Pleasure Seeker! Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99

Sex Is Dirty When Done Right Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99

Tell Me How You Like It Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99
Sale

Marijuana Leaf Shield Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99 $ 1.99

Small Busted Women... Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99

All American Sports Man Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99

A Diamond Is A Girl's Best Friend Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99
Sale

Classic Corvette Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 2.99 Sold Out
Sale

Pick Me Up, Don't Let Me Down Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99 $ 2.99
Sale

I Don't Accept Advice Gracefully Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99 $ 2.99
Sale

Dieter Suffering From Withdrawal! Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99 $ 1.49
Sale

Overflowing With Possibilities Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99 $ 1.49

Stay Drunk Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99

Take This Job And Shove It! Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99

What's Your Name Again? Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99 Sold Out
Sale

Sex Is Not Contagious Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99 $ 1.49

Fantasies Fulfilled Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99

Yes, I'm Drunk! Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99
Sale

Not Cocky... Confident! Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99 $ 2.99
Sale

Not With You Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99 $ 2.99
Sale

Not Permissive, Just Overly Generous Vintage Pin

Strange Ways $ 4.99 $ 1.49