Best Sellers

Shop our most popular products — the fan favorites your fellow Strange Ways shoppers can't stop buying.

SECRET SOCIETY

Want riches? 💀 Join us to earn money back.

SIGN UP TODAY SIGN UP TODAY
Filters
Close
Clear all
Results: 2679 of 2679 products
Sort by:
Filter and sort
Close

Filter and sort

Results: 2679 products

Clear all
Clear all
Results: 2679 products
Clear all
  • Red bumper sticker with white 'HONK' and 'If you have a smooth brain' text

    Smooth Brain Bumper Sticker

    $ 5.99
    $ 5.99
  • Rainbow landscape enamel lapel pin: “This Land Was Made For You and Me” Gold-edged rainbow landscape enamel lapel pin with “This Land Was Made For You and Me”

    This Land Is Your Land Pin

    $ 9.99
    $ 9.99
  • Gold keychain with ring and black round charm, gold lettering and heart cutout.

    Karma Loop Keychain

    $ 7.99
    $ 7.99
    $ 11.99
  • White crew socks with Exhausted American lettering, red/blue stripes, black toe/heel

    Exhausted American Socks

    $ 14.99
    $ 14.99
  • Happy snail enamel pin with yellow body and orange spiral shell

    Happy Snail Pin

    $ 8.99
    $ 8.99
  • Gold-tone hamsa hand and black triangle charm earrings pair Gold-tone hamsa hand and triangle charm earrings in blister packaging

    Mystic Powers Earrings

    $ 21.99
    $ 21.99
  • Paperback cover with bold title text over layered watercolor color bars. Open book with green and rainbow-edged pages featuring short advice quotes.

    Things Are What You Make of Them: Life Advice for Creatives Book

    $ 15.99
    $ 15.99
  • Large sticker with green monster face and ETHICAL CONSUMPTION / EAT THE RICH text Sticker close-up of green monster with horns, teeth, and money-themed ETHICAL CONSUMPTION text

    Ethical Consumption (Eat The Rich) Large Sticker

    $ 5.99
    $ 5.99
  • Navy crew sock with duck and repeated slogan graphic, angled view Navy crew socks with duck and repeated slogan graphic

    Duck Off Socks

    $ 12.99
    $ 12.99
  • Pink chenille heart patch with two cartoon eyes, stitched outline, curved smile Pink and black chenille heart patch with cartoon eye and curved smile

    Third Eye Heart Chenille Patch

    $ 9.99
    $ 9.99
  • Pink bumper sticker with white text: "PRACTICE KINDNESS"

    Practice Kindness Bumper Sticker

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Notepad with “Today’s Garbage” cartoon raccoons and recycling-bin illustration Close-up notepad cover with “Today’s Garbage” cartoon raccoons around a recycling bin

    Today's Garbage Raccoon Notepad

    $ 8.99
    $ 8.99
  • Black crew sock with floral print, pink heel and toe, and 'FUCK AROUND AND FIND OUT' text Black crew socks with floral print, pink cuff stripes, and 'FUCK AROUND AND FIND OUT' text

    Fuck Around And Find Out Socks

    $ 12.99
    $ 12.99
  • Set of two round green fridge magnets: mushroom and snail designs Mushrooms and snail magnets set of 2 in clear display box

    Mushrooms & Snail Magnets (Set of 2)

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Red enamel message lapel pin with blue outline reading “PLEASE BE NICE TO ME”

    Please Be Nice To Me Pin

    $ 8.99
    $ 8.99
  • Watering-can enamel pin with flower art and 'BLOOM WHERE YOU'RE PLANTED' wording Flower watering-can enamel pin reading 'BLOOM WHERE YOU'RE PLANTED'

    Bloom Where You're Planted Pin

    $ 11.99
    $ 11.99
  • Blue unisex graphic T-shirt with New Haven Connecticut front print Blue unisex T-shirt close-up: New Haven Connecticut logo front

    Retro New Haven Connecticut Unisex Shirt - Blue

    $ 27.99
    $ 27.99
  • Embroidered red rectangular patch with yellow ring, black jackalope, and cryptozoology tracking text Embroidered red patch with yellow cryptozoology circle, black jackalope silhouette, and text

    Jackalope Cryptozoology Patch

    $ 7.99
    $ 7.99
  • Cosmic mushroom enamel lapel pin with gold outline and starry night design

    Cosmic Mushroom Pin

    $ 8.99
    $ 8.99
  • Plant Mama enamel pin with blue flower and “PLANT MAMA” text on purple pot

    Plant Mama Pin

    $ 8.99
    $ 8.99
  • Large square back patch with skull holding burning cigarette illustration on dark fabric. Large back patch with skull holding burning cigarette illustration on dark patch over denim.

    Head Of A Skeleton With A Burning Cigarette Large Back Patch

    $ 34.99
    $ 34.99
  • Bumper sticker with black text: "I'd rather be here now"

    I'd Rather Be Here Now Bumper Sticker

    $ 5.99
    $ 5.99
  • Witch baby enamel pin with gold outline, black hat, green face, striped legs Witch baby enamel pin with gold outline, black hat, green face, purple details

    Witch Baby Pin

    $ 8.99
    $ 8.99
  • Round dog dishwasher magnet showing dirty and clean text with white dog holding dish Round dog dishwasher magnet, white dog graphic with Woof speech bubble

    Dirty / Clean Dog Dishwasher Magnet

    $ 5.99
    $ 5.99
  • Silly Goose embroidered patch with white, orange, and black details and text

    Silly Goose Patch

    $ 5.99
    $ 5.99
  • Navy dad hat with cream embroidered "New Haven" logo Navy dad hat with cream embroidered "New Haven"

    New Haven Puff Embroidered Dad Hat - Navy Blue

    $ 27.99
    $ 27.99
  • Red embroidered patch reading 'I HAVE THE DAY YOU deserve'

    The Day You Deserve Patch

    $ 7.99
    $ 7.99
  • Black embroidered patch with bat-like devil graphic and red “Cryptozoology Tracking Society” text Black embroidered patch with red “Cryptozoology Tracking Society” text and “Jersey Devil” design

    Jersey Devil Cryptozoology Patch

    $ 7.99
    $ 7.99
  • Car bumper sticker with bold black text 'MY CAR IS LOUD' and 'PENIS IS BIG' plus portrait

    Car Loud, Penis Big Bumper Sticker

    $ 5.99
    $ 5.99
  • Colorful word patch with raised letters stitching

    Whatever Word Patch

    $ 7.99
    $ 7.99
  • Embroidered black patch with gold border, UFO and cactus, "CRYPTOZOOLOGY" "TRACKING SOCIETY" Embroidered black patch with gold edge, UFO and cactus, "CRYPTOZOOLOGY TRACKING SOCIETY"

    Extraterrestrials Cryptozoology Patch

    $ 7.99
    $ 7.99
  • Green Sasquatch patch with orange figure and CRYPTOZOOLOGY TRACKING SOCIETY text Green Sasquatch embroidered patch with orange figure, moon, stars, and CryptoZoology text

    Sasquatch Cryptozoology Patch

    $ 7.99
    $ 7.99
  • Basic Witches paperback book with illustrated witchcraft symbols on dark cover

    Basic Witches: How To Summon Success, Banish Drama, and Raise Hell With Your Coven

    $ 15.99
    $ 15.99
  • Rectangular enamel pin with black text reading "UNEMPLOYABLE" on a copper border

    Unemployable Pin

    $ 8.99
    $ 8.99
  • Neon green pill case with hinged lid, printed “Meds!” message Open neon green pill organizer case with four compartments and snap lid

    Turns Out All I Needed Was My Meds! Pill Case

    $ 14.99
    $ 14.99
  • Unisex short-sleeve T-shirt, light heather gray, centered tree graphic with New Haven, CT Unisex T-shirt in light heather gray with tree graphic and park text on front

    Wooster Square Park Unisex Shirt

    $ 27.99
    $ 27.99
  • Embroidered circular patch with black border, 'WAITING FOR' text, and dripping flame design

    Societal Collapse Patch

    $ 7.99
    $ 7.99
  • Heather gray unisex T-shirt with black possum graphic and LIVE WEIRD text Heather gray unisex T-shirt close-up of LIVE WEIRD possum graphic

    Live Weird Possum Unisex Shirt

    $ 25.99
    $ 25.99
  • Pink dad hat with front 'DADDY IS A STATE OF MIND' embroidery and curved brim Close-up of pink dad hat with embroidered 'DADDY IS A STATE OF MIND' text

    Daddy Is A State Of Mind Dad Hat

    $ 31.99
    $ 31.99
  • White skull incense burner with incense cones and boxed set White skull incense burner with dish base and rising smoke

    Skull Cone Incense Burner

    $ 17.99
    $ 17.99
SUPPORT ARTISTS

ARTIST DESIGNS

We buy directly from independent makers, or work with them to produce custom product and original ideas.

Express yourself

SELF-EXPRESSION

Our goal is to showcase items that speak to people's personalities, and help customers feel more authentically-you.

SHOP SMALL

SMALL BUSINESS

We are one store run by dedicated people. We do not drop-ship, everything is on-site, and we pack orders every day.

RECENTLY VIEWED

You haven't viewed any products yet.