Items + Gifts Under $5

Shop the best funny, unique, cool, unusual odd artist gifts for Christmas, Valentine's Day, and birthdays. This is everything In Stock in our online shop under $5!

Can't decide on a gift? Get a Strange Ways Gift Card, and they can pick what they want!

Filters
Availability
Reset
Price
$
$
Reset
Color
Reset
Close
Clear all
Results: 160 of 160 products
Sort by:
Filter and sort
Close

Filter and sort

Results: 160 products

Availability
Clear
Price

Up to

Clear
Color
Clear
Clear all
Clear all
Results: 160 products
Clear all
  • Gooey Strange Ways Clear Sticker-Strange Ways-Strange Ways Gooey Strange Ways Clear Sticker-Strange Ways-Strange Ways

    Gooey Strange Ways Clear Sticker

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Break Open, Come Alive Holographic Sticker-Katie Blanchard-Strange Ways Break Open, Come Alive Holographic Sticker-Katie Blanchard-Strange Ways
    Break Open, Come Alive Holographic Sticker-Katie Blanchard-Strange Ways Break Open, Come Alive Holographic Sticker-Katie Blanchard-Strange Ways

    Break Open, Come Alive Holographic Sticker

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Leo Wokeface Zodiac Sticker-Wokeface-Strange Ways Leo Wokeface Zodiac Sticker-Wokeface-Strange Ways

    Leo Wokeface Zodiac Sticker

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Radiant Ageless Beauty Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways Radiant Ageless Beauty Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways
    Radiant Ageless Beauty Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways Radiant Ageless Beauty Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways

    Radiant Ageless Beauty Award Ribbon

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Play With Fire Sticker-Hippie's Daughter-Strange Ways Play With Fire Sticker-Hippie's Daughter-Strange Ways

    Play With Fire Sticker

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Humpty Dumpty Butt Kiss-Cut Sticker-Molly Illustration-Strange Ways Humpty Dumpty Butt Kiss-Cut Sticker-Molly Illustration-Strange Ways
    Humpty Dumpty Butt Kiss-Cut Sticker-Molly Illustration-Strange Ways Humpty Dumpty Butt Kiss-Cut Sticker-Molly Illustration-Strange Ways

    Humpty Dumpty Butt Kiss-Cut Sticker

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • In A Pickle Kiss-Cut Sticker-Molly Illustration-Strange Ways In A Pickle Kiss-Cut Sticker-Molly Illustration-Strange Ways
    In A Pickle Kiss-Cut Sticker-Molly Illustration-Strange Ways In A Pickle Kiss-Cut Sticker-Molly Illustration-Strange Ways

    In A Pickle Kiss-Cut Sticker

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Silly Goose Kiss-Cut Sticker-Molly Illustration-Strange Ways Silly Goose Kiss-Cut Sticker-Molly Illustration-Strange Ways
    Silly Goose Kiss-Cut Sticker-Molly Illustration-Strange Ways Silly Goose Kiss-Cut Sticker-Molly Illustration-Strange Ways

    Silly Goose Kiss-Cut Sticker

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Libra Wokeface Zodiac Sticker-Wokeface-Strange Ways Libra Wokeface Zodiac Sticker-Wokeface-Strange Ways

    Libra Wokeface Zodiac Sticker

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Bilingüe Baby Sticker Holographic Sticker-YayItzel-Strange Ways Bilingüe Baby Sticker Holographic Sticker-YayItzel-Strange Ways
    Bilingüe Baby Sticker Holographic Sticker-YayItzel-Strange Ways Bilingüe Baby Sticker Holographic Sticker-YayItzel-Strange Ways

    Bilingüe Baby Sticker Holographic Sticker

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Be Nice Or Leave Flower Holographic Sticker-YayItzel-Strange Ways Be Nice Or Leave Flower Holographic Sticker-YayItzel-Strange Ways

    Be Nice Or Leave Flower Holographic Sticker

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Support Street Vendors Sticker-Barrio Drive-Strange Ways Support Street Vendors Sticker-Barrio Drive-Strange Ways

    Support Street Vendors Sticker

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Cowgirls Sticker-Barrio Drive-Strange Ways Cowgirls Sticker-Barrio Drive-Strange Ways

    Cowgirls Sticker

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Here, Queer, and Fabulous Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways Here, Queer, and Fabulous Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways
    Here, Queer, and Fabulous Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways Here, Queer, and Fabulous Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways

    Here, Queer, and Fabulous Award Ribbon

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Happy Birthday Geezer Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways Happy Birthday Geezer Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways
    Happy Birthday Geezer Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways Happy Birthday Geezer Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways

    Happy Birthday Geezer Award Ribbon

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Aries Wokeface Zodiac Sticker-Wokeface-Strange Ways Aries Wokeface Zodiac Sticker-Wokeface-Strange Ways

    Aries Wokeface Zodiac Sticker

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Sagittarius Wokeface Zodiac Sticker-Wokeface-Strange Ways Sagittarius Wokeface Zodiac Sticker-Wokeface-Strange Ways

    Sagittarius Wokeface Zodiac Sticker

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Most Lit Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways Most Lit Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways
    Most Lit Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways Most Lit Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways

    Most Lit Award Ribbon

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Body Autonomy For All Holographic Sticker-Golden Gems-Strange Ways Body Autonomy For All Holographic Sticker-Golden Gems-Strange Ways

    Body Autonomy For All Holographic Sticker

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Creativity Is Individuality Sticker-One Lane Road-Strange Ways Creativity Is Individuality Sticker-One Lane Road-Strange Ways

    Creativity Is Individuality Sticker

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Congrats! Bottle Gift Tag Ribbon-Rhino Parade-Strange Ways Congrats! Bottle Gift Tag Ribbon-Rhino Parade-Strange Ways
    Congrats! Bottle Gift Tag Ribbon-Rhino Parade-Strange Ways Congrats! Bottle Gift Tag Ribbon-Rhino Parade-Strange Ways

    Congrats! Bottle Gift Tag Ribbon

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Cheers! Bottle Gift Tag Ribbon-Rhino Parade-Strange Ways Cheers! Bottle Gift Tag Ribbon-Rhino Parade-Strange Ways
    Cheers! Bottle Gift Tag Ribbon-Rhino Parade-Strange Ways Cheers! Bottle Gift Tag Ribbon-Rhino Parade-Strange Ways

    Cheers! Bottle Gift Tag Ribbon

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Get It Girl Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways Get It Girl Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways
    Get It Girl Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways Get It Girl Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways

    Get It Girl Award Ribbon

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Best Of Luck Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways Best Of Luck Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways
    Best Of Luck Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways Best Of Luck Award Ribbon-Yellow Owl Workshop-Strange Ways

    Best Of Luck Award Ribbon

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Extra Deluxe Metal Pin Backs (Pack of 10)-Strange Ways-Strange Ways Extra Deluxe Metal Pin Backs (Pack of 10)-Strange Ways-Strange Ways
    Extra Deluxe Metal Pin Backs (Pack of 10)-Strange Ways-Strange Ways Extra Deluxe Metal Pin Backs (Pack of 10)-Strange Ways-Strange Ways

    Extra Deluxe Metal Pin Backs (Pack of 10)

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Mushrooms Washi Tape-Smarty Pants Paper Co.-Strange Ways Mushrooms Washi Tape-Smarty Pants Paper Co.-Strange Ways
    Mushrooms Washi Tape-Smarty Pants Paper Co.-Strange Ways Mushrooms Washi Tape-Smarty Pants Paper Co.-Strange Ways

    Mushrooms Washi Tape

    $ 4.49
    $ 4.49
  • Eyeballs Washi Tape-Smarty Pants Paper Co.-Strange Ways Eyeballs Washi Tape-Smarty Pants Paper Co.-Strange Ways
    Eyeballs Washi Tape-Smarty Pants Paper Co.-Strange Ways Eyeballs Washi Tape-Smarty Pants Paper Co.-Strange Ways

    Eyeballs Washi Tape

    $ 4.49
    $ 4.49
  • Halloween Every Day Large Magnet-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways Halloween Every Day Large Magnet-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways

    Halloween Every Day Large Magnet

    $ 3.99
    $ 3.99
  • Froget About It Large Magnet-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways Froget About It Large Magnet-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways

    Froget About It Large Magnet

    $ 3.99
    $ 3.99
  • Spooky Idiot Large Magnet-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways Spooky Idiot Large Magnet-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways

    Spooky Idiot Large Magnet

    $ 3.99
    $ 3.99
  • Always Filled With Rage Heart-Shaped Big Pinback Button-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways Always Filled With Rage Heart-Shaped Big Pinback Button-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways
    Always Filled With Rage Heart-Shaped Big Pinback Button-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways Always Filled With Rage Heart-Shaped Big Pinback Button-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways

    Always Filled With Rage Heart-Shaped Big Pinback Button

    $ 3.99
    $ 3.99
  • Friend To Bugs Sticker-Frog and Toad Press-Strange Ways Friend To Bugs Sticker-Frog and Toad Press-Strange Ways

    Friend To Bugs Sticker

    $ 3.99
    $ 3.99
    $ 4.99
  • I Am Woman With Big Buttcheeks Heart-Shaped Big Pinback Button-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways I Am Woman With Big Buttcheeks Heart-Shaped Big Pinback Button-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways
    I Am Woman With Big Buttcheeks Heart-Shaped Big Pinback Button-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways Flop Era Heart-Shaped Big Pinback Button-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways

    I Am Woman With Big Buttcheeks Heart-Shaped Big Pinback Button

    $ 3.99
    $ 3.99
  • I Am Woman With Big Tiddies Heart-Shaped Big Pinback Button-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways I Am Woman With Big Tiddies Heart-Shaped Big Pinback Button-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways
    I Am Woman With Big Tiddies Heart-Shaped Big Pinback Button-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways I Am Woman With Big Tiddies Heart-Shaped Big Pinback Button-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways

    I Am Woman With Big Tiddies Heart-Shaped Big Pinback Button

    $ 3.99
    $ 3.99
  • Tom Of Finland Leatherman Quarter Socks-Gumball Poodle-Strange Ways Tom Of Finland Leatherman Quarter Socks-Gumball Poodle-Strange Ways
    Tom Of Finland Leatherman Quarter Socks-Gumball Poodle-Strange Ways Tom Of Finland Leatherman Quarter Socks-Gumball Poodle-Strange Ways
    Tom Of Finland Leatherman Quarter Socks-Gumball Poodle-Strange Ways Tom Of Finland Leatherman Quarter Socks-Gumball Poodle-Strange Ways

    Tom Of Finland Leatherman Quarter Socks

    $ 3.99
    $ 3.99
    $ 12.99
  • Sniff My Finger Patch-Quiet Tide Goods-Strange Ways Sniff My Finger Patch-Quiet Tide Goods-Strange Ways

    Sniff My Finger Patch

    $ 3.99
    $ 3.99
    $ 9.99
  • Late For My Sadness Nap Sticker-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways Late For My Sadness Nap Sticker-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways

    Late For My Sadness Nap Sticker

    $ 3.99
    $ 3.99
    $ 4.99
  • Tajín Is My Glitter Sticker-YayItzel-Strange Ways Tajín Is My Glitter Sticker-YayItzel-Strange Ways

    Tajín Is My Glitter Sticker

    $ 3.99
    $ 3.99
    $ 4.99
  • Filled With Dread Large Magnet-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways Filled With Dread Large Magnet-Krystan Saint Cat-Strange Ways

    Filled With Dread Large Magnet

    $ 3.99
    $ 3.99
  • Pink Sphynx Cat Mini Sticker Patch-These Are Things-Strange Ways Pink Sphynx Cat Mini Sticker Patch-These Are Things-Strange Ways
    Pink Sphynx Cat Mini Sticker Patch-These Are Things-Strange Ways Pink Sphynx Cat Mini Sticker Patch-These Are Things-Strange Ways

    Pink Sphynx Cat Mini Sticker Patch

    $ 3.49
    $ 3.49
SUPPORT ARTISTS

ARTIST DESIGNS

We buy directly from independent makers, or work with them to produce custom product and original ideas.

Express yourself

SELF-EXPRESSION

Our goal is to showcase items that speak to people's personalities, and help customers feel more authentically-you.

SHOP SMALL

SMALL BUSINESS

We are one store run by dedicated people. We do not drop-ship, everything is on-site, and we pack orders every day.