Best Sellers

Shop our most popular products — the fan favorites your fellow Strange Ways shoppers can't stop buying.

SECRET SOCIETY

Want riches? 💀 Join us to earn money back.

SIGN UP TODAY SIGN UP TODAY
Filters
Close
Clear all
Results: 2679 of 2679 products
Sort by:
Filter and sort
Close

Filter and sort

Results: 2679 products

Clear all
Clear all
Results: 2679 products
Clear all
  • Yellow ceramic mug with black quote text, three handles, front view Yellow ceramic mug with loop handles, front view

    I Literally Do Not Know 3-Handled Mug

    $ 34.99
    $ 34.99
  • Astronaut cat enamel pin, yellow cat in red space suit with curved legs

    Astronaut Cat Pin

    $ 8.99
    $ 8.99
  • Yellow rectangular keychain with text: I literally do not know what I am doing

    Don't Know What I'm Doing Keychain

    $ 14.99
    $ 14.99
  • Isolated large heart back patch: black heart with orange roses and leaf details Large heart back patch with orange roses and black cat-style outline

    Blooming Heart Large Back Patch

    $ 24.99
    $ 24.99
  • Washi tape roll with colorful cartoon fungi on green, reads 'Funguys'.

    Mushrooms Funguys Washi Tape

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Round window decal: rainbow rings with stars, smiling cloud, “LET LIGHT IN” Rainbow prismatic light projection from round window decal on white plant stand

    Let Light In Rainbow Suncatcher Window Decal

    $ 9.99
    $ 9.99
  • Smiling sun rainbow suncatcher window decal with scalloped frame Potted plant in round pot on white metal stand with blue egg ornament

    Good Things On The Horizon Rainbow Suncatcher Window Decal

    $ 9.99
    $ 9.99
  • Round embroidered patch, black with white “Lost in Space” text, stars and crescent moon

    Lost In Space Patch

    $ 5.99
    $ 5.99
  • Rectangular purple enamel lapel pin showing “HELLO! I'M” and “about to choose violence”. Purple enamel lapel pin with text: “HELLO! I'M” and “about to choose violence”.

    Choose Violence Pin

    $ 9.99
    $ 9.99
  • Pair of navy crew socks with captain illustration, red stripes, yellow anchors, teal heel Navy crew socks with cartoon captain graphic, red and yellow accents, teal toe

    Captain Obvious Socks

    $ 12.99
    $ 12.99
  • Pink relationship advice book cover with bold "Unf*ck Your Intimacy" title and subtitle

    Unfuck Your Intimacy Book: Using Science for Better Relationships, Sex, and Dating

    $ 14.99
    $ 14.99
  • Brown coffin-shaped enamel pin with stacked text: THERE / BETTER BE / KITTIES

    Better Be Kitties Coffin Pin

    $ 9.99
    $ 9.99
  • Embroidered turquoise cat patch with striped tail and rainbow 420 banner

    420 Cat Patch

    $ 7.99
    $ 7.99
  • Patchwork jacquard panel baseball cap with multicolor geometric pattern Patchwork jacquard panel cap in multicolor geometric print with black strap

    Jacquard Patchwork Panel Hat

    $ 31.99
    $ 31.99
  • Dark brown circular embroidered patch with white slogan 'PUBLIC LANDS, PUBLIC HANDS'.

    Public Lands, Public Hands Patch

    $ 7.99
    $ 7.99
  • Connecticut quarter magnet coin showing Charter Oak tree, CONNECTICUT 1788 and 1999 Connecticut state quarter-style magnet coin with Charter Oak tree design and 1999 text

    Connecticut State Quarter Magnet

    $ 7.49
    $ 7.49
  • Gold metal keychain with “WILDEST DREAMS” key charm Gold keychain holding “WILDEST DREAMS” key-shaped charm

    Wildest Dreams Keychain

    $ 14.99
    $ 14.99
  • Cartoon dog back patch with speech bubble reading “THIS IS FINE” Square dog back patch, close-up of smiling cartoon dog and “THIS IS FINE.” text

    This Is Fine Dog Large Back Patch

    $ 19.99
    $ 19.99
  • Yale Bulldogs lineup magnet with four bulldogs and letters Y A L E

    Yale Bulldogs Lineup Magnet

    $ 6.99
    $ 6.99
  • Pink heart chenille patch with yellow "Naps" lettering and white border Heart-shaped pink chenille patch reading "Naps" in yellow with white edge trim

    Naps Heart Chenille Patch

    $ 9.99
    $ 9.99
  • Large twin kirpan embroidered patches, black and yellow knife design Single kirpan embroidered patch with black outline and yellow knife motif

    Twin Kirpan Knives Large Patch Set

    $ 19.99
    $ 19.99
  • Light blue crew socks with striped cuff and 'IN DOG YEARS I'M GAY' print

    In Dog Years, I'm Gay Socks

    $ 14.99
    $ 14.99
  • Embroidered rectangular patch with blue border, red "GIDDY UP" text and star accents

    Giddy Up Patch

    $ 7.99
    $ 7.99
  • Round embroidered patch with yellow lettering: MY RECORD COLLECTION IS BETTER THAN YOURS

    My Record Collection Is Better Patch

    $ 7.99
    $ 7.99
  • Green wolf head patch with four eyes, red accents, stitched edge

    4-Eyed Wolf Patch

    $ 9.99
    $ 9.99
  • Three stacked squiggle washi tape rolls in purple, red, teal, and yellow Set of 3 squiggle washi tape rolls in blue, red, purple, and yellow

    Squiggle Colors Washi Tape (Set of 3)

    $ 10.99
    $ 10.99
  • Open green glass jar soy candle with white wax and floral flecks; label and black lid Glass jar soy candle with white wax and scattered dark red flower petals, gold lid

    Vetiver & Poppy Soy Candle (6oz)

    $ 19.99
    $ 19.99
  • Cat bumper magnet with white-and-blue cat and colorful text: “My cat is getting lonely!”

    My Cat Is Getting Lonely Bumper Magnet

    $ 9.99
    $ 9.99
  • Yellow crew socks with colorful mushroom and butterfly pattern Worn yellow crew socks with mushroom and butterfly print, ankle length

    Mushroom Butterfly Socks

    $ 12.99
    $ 12.99
  • Purple crew socks with repeating pixel art game pattern, cushioned toe Purple crew socks with colorful retro video game icons

    Retro Gamer Socks

    $ 9.99
    $ 9.99
    $ 12.99
  • Mystery sticker pack card, text “Mystery Stickers” and “3 for $10” with theme prompt

    Mystery Sticker Pack (3 for $10)

    $ 9.99
    $ 9.99
  • Stacked prompt cards with blue striped cover and beige card with handwritten-style quote Stack of prompt cards showing beige 'Be honest...' quote and blue 'Excuses to Celebrate' cover

    Excuses To Celebrate Card Deck Prompts

    $ 19.99
    $ 19.99
  • Guided journal cover with colorful doodle pattern and blue title text 'STORIES WE TELL'. Guided journal page with black prompt text: What role has friendship played?

    Stories We Tell Guided Journal

    $ 17.99
    $ 17.99
  • Enamel evil eye mushroom pin with colorful top and black stem with sparkle accents

    Evil Eye Mushroom Pin

    $ 8.99
    $ 8.99
  • Monster head patch with teal stitched face, orange eyes, black border and wavy mouth

    Lagoon Creature Monster Head Patch

    $ 8.99
    $ 8.99
  • Row of multicolor heart enamel pins in rainbow colors with black outlines Rainbow heart enamel pin with row of multicolor hearts on white backing fabric

    Rainbow Hearts LGBTQ+ Pin

    $ 7.99
    $ 7.99
    $ 9.99
  • Colorful gummy worm stud earrings with blue/orange and yellow/green enamel Gummy worm stud earrings with blue and orange enamel details

    Gummy Worm Earrings

    $ 14.99
    $ 14.99
  • Gold-tone ghost stud earring and black Ouija heart stud earring set Ghost and Ouija heart charm earrings, gold-tone with enamel accents

    Ghost & Ouija Earrings

    $ 21.99
    $ 21.99
  • Jolene pin with cursive script logo, copper-tone metal finish.

    Jolene Pin

    $ 10.99
    $ 10.99
  • Medieval nail art sticker set on card, gold and multicolor decals, 322 count. Gold and green manicure nails with animal silhouettes and ornate crescent symbols.

    Illuminated Medieval Nail Art Stickers (322ct)

    $ 19.99
    $ 19.99
SUPPORT ARTISTS

ARTIST DESIGNS

We buy directly from independent makers, or work with them to produce custom product and original ideas.

Express yourself

SELF-EXPRESSION

Our goal is to showcase items that speak to people's personalities, and help customers feel more authentically-you.

SHOP SMALL

SMALL BUSINESS

We are one store run by dedicated people. We do not drop-ship, everything is on-site, and we pack orders every day.

RECENTLY VIEWED

You haven't viewed any products yet.