Best Sellers

Shop our most popular products — the fan favorites your fellow Strange Ways shoppers can't stop buying.

SECRET SOCIETY

Want riches? 💀 Join us to earn money back.

SIGN UP TODAY SIGN UP TODAY
Filters
Close
Clear all
Results: 2679 of 2679 products
Sort by:
Filter and sort
Close

Filter and sort

Results: 2679 products

Clear all
Clear all
Results: 2679 products
Clear all
  • Pasta-shaped floor mat rug, yellow textured bow with V-shaped center opening Pasta-shaped floor mat rug with yellow textured bow design and curved center notch

    Farfalle Pasta Floor Mat Rug

    $ 34.99
    $ 34.99
  • Square magnet showing Wooster Square tree and bench, text WOOSTER SQUARE Angled square magnet with tree canopy, bench, and WOOSTER SQUARE text

    Wooster Square Park Magnet

    $ 7.99
    $ 7.99
  • Purple unicorn crew socks with black band and snowflake print, graphic unicorns Purple crew socks with black cuff band, 'FUCK YES' text and unicorn print

    You Glorious Bitch Unicorn Socks

    $ 12.99
    $ 12.99
  • Prismatic unicorn sticker with rainbow mane, star accents, and slogan text 'Being mean to me is illegal'. Prismatic unicorn sticker with rainbow mane, stars, and slogan 'Being mean to me is illegal'.

    Being Mean To Me Is Illegal Prismatic Sticker

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Pill bottle shaker keychain with key ring, LEXAPRO label, clear orange pill base Shaker pill bottle keychain with silver key ring, clear case, orange-yellow pills

    Silly Lexapro Pill Bottle Shaker Keychain (Moving Parts)

    $ 17.99
    $ 17.99
  • Embroidered strawberry face patch with green leaves and yellow accents

    Strawbebby Patch

    $ 7.99
    $ 7.99
  • Three stacked squiggle washi tape rolls in purple, red, teal, and yellow Set of 3 squiggle washi tape rolls in blue, red, purple, and yellow

    Squiggle Colors Washi Tape (Set of 3)

    $ 10.99
    $ 10.99
  • Skeleton sticker in black and white with bold text "FOR FUCK’S SAKE"

    For Fuck's Sake Skeleton Sticker

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
  • Circular embroidered patch with black border, cartoon toaster, bubbles, and 'Live Laugh' text

    Live, Laugh, Toaster Bath Patch

    $ 7.99
    $ 7.99
  • Rectangular enamel style lapel pin with quote and fish graphic

    Buy A Man Eat Fish Pin

    $ 10.99
    $ 10.99
  • New Haven railroad refrigerator magnet with Greater Power logo and vintage train photo Greater Power New Haven railroad-themed refrigerator magnet with vintage train artwork

    Greater Power New Haven Railroad Magnet

    $ 6.99
    $ 6.99
  • Incense cone with terracotta-style holder, shown with boxed packaging

    Frankincense Incense Cones (14ct)

    $ 7.99
    $ 7.99
  • Black fleece slippers (pair) with beige lining and white skull 'Death Before Decaf' text Black fleece slippers worn on feet with white skull 'Death Before Decaf' logo

    Death Before Decaf Unisex Fleece Slippers

    $ 29.99
    $ 29.99
  • Round Star Baker pin with red star, white text, and gold outline Star Baker enamel pin with red star logo and yellow border

    Star Baker Pin

    $ 10.99
    $ 10.99
  • Blue embroidered shield patch with Kraken Dive Team text and tentacle graphic

    Kraken Dive Team Patch

    $ 8.99
    $ 8.99
  • Strawberry milk carton enamel pin with red strawberry icon

    Strawberry Milk Pin

    $ 8.99
    $ 8.99
  • ADHD AF enamel lapel pin with pink and yellow letters on black backing ADHD AF enamel lapel pin with colorful letter design and black edging

    ADHD AF Pin

    $ 11.99
    $ 11.99
  • Mycocultural Revolution book with red cover and mushroom, lichen, and fungi artwork

    The Mycocultural Revolution Book: Transforming Our World with Mushrooms, Lichens, and Other Fungi

    $ 17.99
    $ 17.99
  • Embroidered Bigfoot Army patch: bear in mountains, 'BIGFOOT ARMY' text, yellow chevrons

    Bigfoot Army Patch

    $ 6.99
    $ 6.99
    $ 8.99
  • Night Watch owl biker patch with orange-and-black embroidered owl and arched text

    Night Watch Owl Biker Patch

    $ 6.99
    $ 6.99
    $ 9.99
  • Green fish mug with pink interior and white-red bobber tea infuser Green fish tea mug with red bobber infuser, white scoop, and red refill tray

    Fish Mug w/ Bobber Tea Infuser

    $ 19.99
    $ 19.99
  • Rectangular flower pride patch with multicolor floral design and 'WE JUST WANT TO BLOOM'

    Flower Pride Flag Patch

    $ 9.99
    $ 9.99
  • Medieval nail art sticker set on card, gold and multicolor decals, 322 count. Gold and green manicure nails with animal silhouettes and ornate crescent symbols.

    Illuminated Medieval Nail Art Stickers (322ct)

    $ 19.99
    $ 19.99
  • New Haven Connecticut license plate ornament, front reads NEW HAVEN, Constitution State New Haven Connecticut license plate ornament with hanging cord, reads NEW HAVEN

    New Haven Connecticut License Ornament

    $ 8.99
    $ 8.99
  • Red embroidered patch with gold border, 'OH, HELL YES!' text

    Oh, Hell Yes! Patch

    $ 8.99
    $ 8.99
  • Rectangular embroidered patch: red Born to Win text with playing card icons on cream

    Born To Win Patch

    $ 8.99
    $ 8.99
  • Round duck cartoon enamel pin with 'BECOME UNGOVERNABLE' text

    Become Ungovernable Duck Pin

    $ 10.99
    $ 10.99
  • Cunty mini hairbrush, pink translucent oval brush with red beaded lettering Cunty mini hairbrush, pink translucent brush pad with red beaded design

    Cunty Mini Hairbrush

    $ 19.99
    $ 19.99
  • Enamel "Touch Grass" pin with layered green and blue trees and orange ribbon banner. Colorful enamel forest pin with gold outline and orange "Touch Grass" banner.

    Touch Grass Pin

    $ 8.99
    $ 8.99
  • Amber glass soy candle jar with black lid and single flame Soy candle in dark-rim glass with cream wax and small wick at center

    Basil & Amber Soy Candle (6oz)

    $ 19.99
    $ 19.99
  • Embroidered road safety patch with Bigfoot, blue truck, moonlit trees, and bold text Square embroidered patch showing Bigfoot and blue truck with 'WATCH THE ROAD' wording

    Sasquatch Road Safety Large Patch

    $ 10.99
    $ 10.99
  • Gold mermaid enamel pin with curled hair and fish-scale tail

    Golden Mermaid Pin

    $ 8.99
    $ 8.99
  • Auroshikha lemongrass incense cones, cone on terracotta holder and green box

    Lemongrass Incense Cones (14ct)

    $ 4.99
    $ 4.99
    $ 7.99
  • Green cactus enamel pin with arms out and “FREE HUGS” plate

    Free Hugs Cactus Pin

    $ 8.99
    $ 8.99
  • Large back patch with embroidered crossed fingers and two outlined hands Embroidery detail: crossed-fingers hand graphic on long stitched patch

    Fingers Crossed Large Back Patch

    $ 20.99
    $ 20.99
  • Rats risograph art print (11 x 14 in) with black rat silhouettes and quote Cropped rats risograph art print with large quote text and black animal silhouettes

    The Rats Inspiring Risograph Art Print (11" x 14")

    $ 14.99
    $ 14.99
  • Floral enamel pin shaped like a head silhouette holding flowers Floral enamel pin featuring bouquet outlines in a head silhouette

    Give Flowers Pin

    $ 9.99
    $ 9.99
  • Red and black gothic cathedral patch with twin towers and arched center emblem Black and red stitched gothic cathedral patch with twin towers and center rose

    Gothic Cathedral Patch

    $ 10.99
    $ 10.99
  • Kitchen Witch book titled Kitchen Witch with natural remedies and crafts cover

    Kitchen Witch Book: Natural Remedies and Crafts for Home, Health, and Beauty

    $ 19.99
    $ 19.99
  • Green sea turtle enamel pin with 'GOOD VIBES' and dotted underside details Green enamel sea turtle pin with 'GOOD VIBES' and shell dots

    Good Vibes Sea Turtle Pin

    $ 9.99
    $ 9.99
SUPPORT ARTISTS

ARTIST DESIGNS

We buy directly from independent makers, or work with them to produce custom product and original ideas.

Express yourself

SELF-EXPRESSION

Our goal is to showcase items that speak to people's personalities, and help customers feel more authentically-you.

SHOP SMALL

SMALL BUSINESS

We are one store run by dedicated people. We do not drop-ship, everything is on-site, and we pack orders every day.

RECENTLY VIEWED

You haven't viewed any products yet.